Captain’s Coming
The first day I woke up inside the school, I remembered nothing. Not even my name.
I was bleary eyed and blinking at a wall such a blistering shade of violet it almost made me sick. Right above my head was a toilet that looked like it was made for somebody around three and a half feet tall. Bathroom?
I attempted to dive into the consciousness of memory to find an inkling of context for why I was passed out in a tiny bathroom, but nothing surfaced.
Who even was I? Before that thought could linger for more than a second, I heard a man’s voice muffled by the old wooden door.
“We know better now. We can modify the plan. I say—”
“No.”
The second voice belonged to a woman. I leaned against the door to hear her better, but ended up hitting my head with a hard thump on the wood. There was silence, then shuffling footsteps and a jiggling of the bathroom door handle. I tumbled forward and landed flat on my stomach, looking up to see the face of a man who looked to be in his mid-twenties with a silver piercing below his bottom lip. I couldn’t place where I knew him from.
“Eavesdropping?” he asked, the left side of his lip quirking. The answer, of course, was yes. But it was totally circumstantial, I wanted to say. I found the pool from which I fish speaking words was unceremoniously dry. After a beat of waiting, the man hauled me up to balance on my own two feet.
I was in an elementary school classroom filled with tiny desks and a vast blackboard with a white chalky tint. The strange difference was that it looked like a warzone—papers strewn across the floor, supplies torn from a tan metal cupboard, and a few desks turned on their sides to create a sort of barricade near the door.
“It shouldn’t be time for another one yet.”
I met the glare of a woman sitting perched atop a school desk with pin-straight, green-dyed hair. I felt my breath hitch in my chest as her sharp brown eyes scanned my face.
“We lost Carlo like two days ago. Why is she here?”
The man looked at me sympathetically. “Be nice. Gracie’s just up. We don’t want to spook her.”
“Good luck with that,” the girl rolled her eyes, but then she looked past me, her gaze becoming distant and her voice becoming soft. “This place is a nightmare.”
That name—Gracie—seemed to be mine. And it was almost right, in a way that’s like the truth tilted on the side. I’m Gracie, or I was. The two strangers watched me for a moment, but no, with each second that passed I decided that their faces were not strange at all.
“I… know you.”
Memories flashed in my mind, pieces of a picture I couldn’t fully paint. I saw the woman, but her cheeks were rounder and her hair was a sunny blonde color pulled into two long braids. And the man I saw much smaller, his curls grown out into an afro that shielded the shape of his jaw. They looked a bit older now—perhaps twenty-one or twenty-two.
The woman crossed her legs on top of the school desk and introduced herself as Abbie Fisher. And it clicked. Abbie Fisher—the girl who lived down four blocks from me, who’d sat alone in the front row of the bus as we rode to this school. Abbie Fisher who moved away in the seventh grade after her older sister died. And the man, he was Brian Peters—he’d been the type of kid that always volunteered to sit with the new kid at lunch. How could I not have remembered them?
“You've got the quickest returning memory I’ve ever seen,” Brian said.
“Just because she’s got our names doesn’t mean she’ll be any good,” Abbie shot.
Brian took my hand and led me over to sit on one of the classroom desks, then produced a small water bottle for me to take sips from.
“Right, Gracie. What I’m about to say is going to sound bizarre, but I need you to stay with me, okay?”
I nodded. Brian then told me the strangest thing I had ever heard. Granted, considering I could only remember back about three minutes, the bar wasn’t set very high. But what he said was absurd. He told me this was our old Sleepy Hollow Elementary, but it was different, wrong. It was like its own universe with windows permanently shut and doors to the outside that never opened. We were trapped here, he said. And that wasn’t even the worst of it.
“There’s this… monster-man. He wears this navy uniform and has no face so we call him... The Captain…”
Abbie’s face seemed to pale at that name. Brian paused to take a deep breath after barely choking out the name. Truthfully, I was too confused to be scared.
Then the fluorescent lights above our heads began to flicker, and Brian leapt off the desk to my left and was at the rainbow cubbies in two steps, tossing backpacks our way. I caught mine against my stomach and mimicked the other two in sliding the straps over my shoulders.
“Captain’s coming.”
Brain and Abbie rushed into the hall. I stuttered before following. These people wore faces from my childhood, but could I trust them? I couldn’t remember anything about myself besides my own name and the fact that I supposedly knew them. Perhaps they were luring me into a sacrifice for this supposed Captain.
No. I shook my head to clear that thought. Going off on my own would mean facing this Captain without my bearings or my memories. Trusting Abbie and Brian was my only choice.
The first day was all hiding. Abbie Fisher seemed to run paths through the school like a reflex, turning corners without a moment’s notice and Brian and I hurrying to catch up. Her hair was the same shade of green as the highlighters on the teacher’s desks and it was the best way to keep track of her as she took us to new hiding spots. Sometimes, she’d just run, even if the Captain wasn’t coming. There was never any warning, and she certainly never looked back to see if we followed. Brian said not to take it personally, that she knew we’d follow.
After each time we saw the Captain, which mostly consisted of hiding under tables and in cabinets, Abbie took out this yellow notebook paper from her pocket and scribbled on it. She always positioned her arm so the page was hidden.
“It’s her theory list,” Brian explained while Abbie was sleeping, propping himself up to sit on an old student's desk. “I asked her why she writes stuff down after attacks once. Don’t do that, by the way. She’ll rip your head off.”
“What’d she say?”
“Told me to leave it alone. I think she’s writing down theories for how to escape, maybe even to outsmart the Captain.”
I leaned forward, interested. “Have you seen them—the theories?”
He shook his head, looking tired.
“How long have you been here, Brian?”
“If I’m right, it’s been four months.”
“And Abbie?”
I looked over to the woman in the corner of the classroom, curled up in one of the tiny purple plush reading chairs that kids probably used to fight over for silent reading time.
Brian followed my gaze. “Once, she just said a few more weeks than you. But the more I watch her, I think it's been a lot longer.”
Brian leaned his elbows on the desk in front of him. “You can tell, you know, that she’s used to being alone. She doesn’t take well to new people, always keeps away from our third when one appears. And then they get caught and she’s just… blank about it. Like losing a new person is a relief or something, like she knew it would happen.”
Something in Abbie’s dreams caused her to frown, and she curled closer into her chest.
“Why do you stick with her then?”
Brian’s fingers traced idly over the stray pencil marks etched into the desk.
“There's a person under all that toughness. I’ve met her before—rarely, when it’s just the two of us. That person wants us both to survive, so I stay.”
Abbie never offered to share the theory list with me, and I never asked to see it.
Five days after I awoke, we went to the art room in search of fabric. Brian tore a hole in the knee of his jeans, and Abbie swore she could sew it. I watched Abbie silently loop stitches into the hole when the lights began to flicker.
Brian dove for the supply closet, and Abbie crawled underneath the table directly across the row from mine. I had nowhere to hide but underneath the table I was at. A minute later, the lights shut off completely and I blinked a few times to readjust to the darkness. The art room door groaned open, and I turned my head just slightly to see a pair of stark white rubber shoes between the legs of tables and chairs. I looked up to see a nearly seven-foot-tall figure in an ironed navy blue suit jacket and bleach white officer cap. The Captain had no face—just a blank slate where features should be. His uniform was pristine, three golden buttons shining down the front and the linen looking fresh off an ironing board.
I held my breath and pressed my shaking hands underneath my armpits as he strode into the room. The Captain walked row to row, past each table, and stopped at the front of the classroom, mere feet from the table where Abbie hid.
For the first time, Abbie and I found ourselves looking directly at each other. Her eyes seemed to widen to unbelievable size and her mouth parted just slightly, as if to speak, or to scream. If the Captain bent down, she’d be right there, helplessly scrunched in a ball like a little girl playing hide and seek. The Captain would kill her.
It was in that moment that I decided I never wanted to die caught hiding.
The Captain walked back the way he came and departed from the room. Abbie and I held each other's stare in the darkness, and I felt too transfixed by her sudden attention to look away. Then, without preamble, Abbie stood up and strutted right past me to grab a bucket of pencils. She produced the theory list from the pocket of her jeans.
I stayed rooted in my spot, thinking of the Captain’s featureless face and the lives it had taken before my arrival. Other former classmates of ours had died at the hands of the Captain before—that much I knew—but Abbie and Brian never told me how the Captain killed people. I started thinking that was a question I never wanted the answer to.
Eventually, I tried to lean my head to see what Abbie was scribbling, but it was at this moment that Brian pulled me out from under the table.
We were always on the run, taking coverage in all of their usual hiding spots. Memories of before started slowly wiggling their way back into my brain, but not the sort I was longing for. I was desperate to recall more about myself—my job, the foods I ate, whom I loved. It was like the universe was giving me crumbs of life, but only the pieces it cared to show. For some reason, young Abbie Fisher saturated those pieces. I remembered that she was the best at drawing portraits before she moved away. In the sixth grade, the art teacher told her she had potential. It wasn’t just the sort of fluffy compliment that teachers tend to give—she meant it with Abbie. The faces Abbie drew had eyes that looked so real, even in pencil, that you’d think they might blink. They really stared at you.
I tried to ask Abbie about her art, but she seized up like all her muscles had gone stiff and stalked away. Brian followed her to the other side of the room and began to whisper to her. I leaned back in my seat, feeling an odd tenseness build in my chest.
The memory of the art room attack sat deep in my chest. I remembered Abbie’s wide eyes, the expression just before speaking crossing her face. She hadn’t said anything after, and I assumed that—like me—the encounter had shaken her. There was something about seeing a person’s face right before they were going to die that sticks in your head. What, I wondered, did it look like from the other side?
Two weeks after my waking, our provisions ran low enough that we were forced to set up camp in the cafeteria. Brian secured the exits while Abbie and I raided the kitchen to stock up. The kitchen was full, as if the next day the front doors would swing open and kids would come pouring in.
“Why doesn’t this place ever run out of food?” I asked.
Abbie paused in her pillaging of the fridge for apple juice cartons and turned to me.
“God, I don’t know, Gracie. Why can’t we walk out the front door?” She snapped.
After we filled our packs, Abbie and I sat silently next to each other on the ground, sipping boxes of sugary juice.
“Do you remember your goodbye party?” I blurted, then blushed fiercely. It was a stupid question, but I’d dreamt of it last night: my mom had sent me with a set of oil pastels and drawing paper to give as a gift. Abbie Fisher’s house had been mostly packed up, so me and a few other girls that her mom invited sat in a circle on her living room floor in a sea of boxes and ate pizza.
Abbie shook her head, but her jaw was clenched tightly.
I remembered that day so clearly. After all the other girls had left, we’d stood together under the light on her front porch while I waited for my ride and she’d given me a portrait of my own face. I didn’t even know she drew me. We weren’t friends, not really. Just distant neighbors. But I looked at that picture and saw how real my own eyes looked on the page, crinkled with delicate lines at the corners. I had no idea she’d ever looked at me long enough to know those sorts of details about my face. I tried to hug her, but she shrugged me off.
Even before waking up here, that memory had been lost.
“Do you still draw, at least?”
“Does it matter?” Abbie asked at last.
“Sure.” I shrugged. “Why wouldn’t it matter?”
She didn’t respond, and we resolved to sip our juice in silence.
We could never truly pause—or properly rest—with the knowledge that the Captain could be right around the corner. No day ever felt like it had a conclusion. Our sense of day and night was always uprooted by close calls causing us to be roused from sleep. One minute I’d be dreaming, the next shaken awake by a sharp-eared Brian who’d sworn he heard footsteps.
At the end of my third week, we made our way to the library. It seemed like a great space to stay with carpets in a shade of maroon that you could lie down on and feel your back muscles relax. The shelves offered the sort of privacy where we could all feel alone but still be close by if something happened. The only problem was a big glass window looking into the hall next to the only entrance. That certainly wasn’t good in case the Captain came striding down the hall.
Luckily, our little group came up with a solution. Brian handed me a stack of thick construction paper colored in autumn tones of orange, yellow, and brown. Then from his pocket he produced a roll of masking tape and began to tape over the large glass window at the front of the library. Perhaps if we take the time to cover the windows that looked into the hallway, the Captain would walk right by. Maybe he’d be dumb and miss us over and over again because our construction paper plan was so smart. We wouldn’t have to face him for so long that it could feel like regular life for a little while. It was a naïve hope.
“Start on the left, work your way towards the middle,” Brian instructed. I took a few sheets of paper and began fixing them to the window, careful to leave no cracks in between the taped-up pages for light to seep through.
My mind fixated on Abbie’s theory list. Was it possible that she’d figured out a way to escape? There must’ve been a secret door, or maybe the Captain had a lair underneath the school that led to the outside world. Her observations must've led to some conclusion. You couldn’t live in a mystery as long as she did and not have any kernel of truth in your theories.
Brian and I covered the window entirely. We could only hope our plan would provide us some reprieve.
Brian wandered into the shelves to see if the school had an Atlas to page through. I walked over to the librarian's desk where Abbie was—oddly, considering no attack had occurred—scribbling on her theory list.
I watched her for a moment, then decided there was no reason to wait in asking.
“Brian told me about that.” I nodded towards her paper. “Your theory list… we could try one, you know.”
Abbie stopped working. “No.”
“Look, I know you won't even let him see them. But maybe if we all looked at them together, we could think of—”
“No.”
Suddenly, Brian was at my side. “Come on, Ab. Gracie’s right. Maybe fighting back—”
Abbie’s stare hit Brian so hard I wondered how he didn’t melt. “Fighting back is the reason most people here don’t survive more than a month. We’re never fighting back again.”
Brian squared his shoulders. “Those people died for nothing if we don’t keep trying to get the hell out of here. You’ve got that list? Share it. Nobody knows the Captain like you do, Ab.”
Abbie’s eyes flicked between Brian and me. “You know what? I’m tired of being pestered by you two all of the time. I’m done.”
Brian frowned. “What? You’re going to leave?”
“I can survive on my own.”
And then Abbie Fisher departed our group, storming out the door of the library like we were just two acquaintances she’d had a fight with.
“Unbelievable,” Brian huffed.
I tried to apologize to him. Somehow, this seemed like my fault. I had brought up the theory list knowing Brian said to leave the topic alone.
“No, Gracie. You can’t blame yourself. She’s just being selfish.”
That’s when the lights began to flicker. Brian and I both gasped, our heads whirling to look at the door Abbie had just marched out of.
A second later, she burst back through it, the blood drained from her face.
“He’s seen me,” Abbie heaved. “Oh my god, Bri. He’s seen me. We’re not getting out.”
Brain shook his head. “Wait. Calm down, okay? We just need to—”
But Brian abruptly stuttered to a halt as we all encountered the same horrific view. Through the paper covered window we all saw the familiar tall silhouette that haunted us.
“I’m sorry,” Abbie whispered. “I’m always so careful, but this time I didn’t check. I was so mad I just ran into the hall and he was right there.”
“Why isn’t he coming in?” I asked. Abbie turned her head back to look at the shadow in the window.
“I don’t know. But he will, soon.”
Brian and I stood stricken. Normally, when the Captain would appear, Abbie would know another way out, or we could hide because he just happened upon our hiding spot. But today, she just stood still.
“Abbie,” Brian said gently. “If you’ve got any ideas on how to get out of here, now is the time to share them.”
Abbie only seemed to look more miserable. She looked from Brian to me and sniffled. Then, she produced the theory list and pressed it into my hands. I blinked, surprised to feel the delicate weight of the paper entrusted to me. Then, gingerly, my eyes fell to the paper in my hand. And after a moment, I ceased to breathe.
Brian was wrong. It wasn’t a list of theories. It was names.
Names of everyone who has ever been the third member of Brian and Abbie’s trio, names of everyone who she had watched die. And above each name, a small sketched pair of eyes.
She had seen their deaths, every one. And in that last moment, she had seen their eyes, seen their fear and wonder and questioning at what would happen next. Abbie saw it all, and she drew it.
My head rose up to look at my two companions.
“Oh God, Abbie, I—” Brian took a single step towards her.
Abbie put her hands up to stop him. “My first week here, I tried every door handle. I snuck into the main office and the gymnasium and even went down to the custodial entrance. Every door was locked. After that, I tried every window. All locked. I crawled into the ventilation systems to see where they led. Nothing works.”
“But maybe—” Brian began, but the shape of Abbie’s words made it sickeningly clear.
She looked right at me, right into my eyes with a pleading look.
“There is no way out,” I said softly.
Brian spun to me. “Don’t let her convince you of that. She’s just panicking because it looks like we’re stuck.”
Indeed, the Captain should’ve come in by now. He seemed to be waiting, though for what reason was still unclear.
I took another long look at the list. “We’re just stuck here, Bri. Destined to run around and hide as long as we can, until that thing snatches us up. There is no other way.”
“No… Abbie’s list! A list of theories should—”
But the list was clearly a lie. Abbie wasn’t trying to find a way out, she was recounting memories of everything that had happened inside.
A single tear slipped down Brian’s cheek. He turned on his heel and quickly disappeared into the shelves. Abbie then turned to face me.
“At some point, you just have to stop hiding from what’s haunting you, look it in the eyes, and face it.”
I dully nodded, the heavy realization sinking like a stone in water in the center of my chest. I finally saw what Abbie knew and Brian didn’t. There was no way out of being chased by death.
Inch by inch, the library’s door handle began to turn.
“I’m tired of being afraid,” Abbie whispered. “I’m tired of seeing it all, and I’m tired of being afraid.”
The door began to swing open. Abbie’s eyes were puffy and rimmed red from crying, but in the middle of it all I saw her take three steady breaths.
We could still run. Perhaps Brian had found a vent for us to crawl through that the Captain could not follow us into. But we would never escape the Captain, not really. One day he would catch us. So we could run and run and delay the day, trying to make the most out of our limited time, or we could submit and let him take us right now. It was our choice. Heart hammering in my chest, I squeezed Abbie’s hand in mine and pulled her away from the door just as the Captain stepped inside the library.